Friday, September 17, 2010

Letter to Madeleine Hamelin, Personal Assisant to the Minister of Transport, Chuck Strahl

Madeleine Hamelin
Personal Assistant to the Minister
Minister of Transport, Infrastructure and Communities
Tower C, Ottawa
Ontario K1A 0N5

September 17, 2010

Dear Ms. Hamelin :

As discussed on the phone with you earlier today, I am writing to request the time, date and place of the session in which the preliminary results of the 15 passenger van safety review will be presented at the Council of Ministers meeting in Halifax. The safety review was announced on June 25 by former federal Transport Minister John Baird . See "Government of Canada launches a safety review of vans used for student transportation" at

At your suggestion, I have also written to your colleague, Jeff Howard, Senior Policy Advisor, Transport Canada, to request observer status for our group at the above stated session.

We have been in contact with Peter Burns, Chief, Ergonomics and Crash Avoidance, Transport Canada. Mr. Burns advised us on September 3, 2010, that the preliminary results of the safety review will be presented at the COM meeting on September 30, 2010.

I quote Mr. Burns :

"Consistent with the former Minister of Transport's news release, the department has been assessing the safety of extracurricular activity vehicles for student transportation. We have been conducting tests to determine the rollover threshold and braking performance of these vehicles and are assessing available field data and collision investigations.

The review is still underway and the preliminary results of our assessments will be presented at the Council of Ministers meeting in Halifax on September 30th."

As you may know, we mothers from Bathurst, New Brunswick have been instrumental in raising the profile of the 15 passenger van issue nationally and internationally since the deaths of our sons in the Boys in Red tragedy. Other parents and concerned citizens have also joined us in our quest to improve student transportation safety, including Stella Gurr, a mother from Nanaimo, British Columbia, who lost her son Michael Gurr in a 15 passenger van roll over in September, 2008. With the announcement by the former Minister following so closely on the heels of the introduction of Private Members Bill C-522 by our Member of Parliament, Yvon Godin (Acadie-Bathurst) to ban 15 passenger vans for student use across Canada, we feel it is appropriate that we be allowed to attend the session which will deal with 15 passenger van safety, since it is the death of our sons that led to this safety review.

We would also like to distribute an information package to members of the COM which contains up to date information on the issue of 15 passenger vans versus 21 passenger Multi Function Activity Vehicles (MFAVs). You are aware that 15 passenger vans were banned for student transportation in New Brunswick following the Bathurst tragedy, but they had previously been banned by Nova Scotia in 1996. In July 2008, six months after our sons were killed, Quebec also banned the use of these vans for student transportation. Throughout the rest of the country there is a patchwork of rules and regulations governing student transportation and we feel that the review will show that these vehicles must be permanently banned before there is another Boys in Red tragedy in Canada.

If you have any questions about this request, I can be reached by telephone during the work week at 506-546-6370 or by cel at 506-544-0533 after 3 pm New Brunswick time.

Thanking you in advance for your cooperation and hoping to receive a reply as soon as possible.


Isabelle Hains


Minister Chuck Strahl, Transport, Infrastructure and Communities

Deputy Minister, Yaprak Baltacioglu, Transport, Infrastructure and Communities

Yvon Godin, Member of Parliament, Bathurst-Acadie

David J. Johnstone, Deputy Minister of Transportation, Province of New Brunswick

M Gravel, Secretary, Council of Ministers and Deputy Ministers Responsible for Transportation and Highway Safety

John Pearson, Project Director, Council of Ministers and Deputy Ministers Responsible for Transportation and Highway Safety

Jeff Howard, Special Policy Advisor, Transport Canada

Peter Burns, Chief, Ergonomics and Crash Avoidance, Transport Canada

Stella Gurr, Nanaimo, British Columbia

Bryan Murphy, Safety Advocate, CUPE 606, Nanaimo, BC

Delalene Harris-Foran, President, CUPE 1253, New Brunswick

Melynda Jarratt, Fredericton, NB